The Joke

Album: By The Way, I Forgive You (2017)
Play Video

Songfacts®:

  • Brandi Carlile wrote "The Joke" as a comment on the sociopolitical climate following the 2016 US presidential election.

    Let 'em laugh while they can
    Let 'em spin, let 'em scatter in the wind
    I have been to the movies, I've seen how it ends
    And the joke's on them


    Carlile explained to NPR that "there are so many people feeling misrepresented. So many people feeling unloved. The song is just for people that feel under-represented, unloved or illegal."
  • Producer Dave Cobb encouraged Carlile to be vocally ambitious on this track. The singer explained to Billboard:

    Dave Cobb loves [Presley's] 'An American Trilogy' and wanted me to understand the emotion and intensity Elvis put into it when we were working on 'The Joke.'"
  • This won the Grammy Award for Best American Roots Song at the 2019 ceremony, where Carlile also performed the song. By The Way, I Forgive You also won for Best Americana Album.
  • The 2019 Right Behind You American Express ad features a little girl playing this song on her violin.
  • In Carlile's mind, recording the album was a means to an end so she could get the songs out on the road, which made it hard for her to access her emotions in the studio.

    "I just didn't know how to show genuine emotion without the audience," she told Stereogum in 2021. "I didn't know how to lose myself in my vocal performances. I don't know if it's something I had unlearned or if I just didn't know, but by the end of the record, I was feeling really opened up spiritually, and it ended on 'The Joke.'"

    Carlile was disappointed that her spiritual breakthrough didn't occur until the album wrapped, so she decided to pick up where "The Joke" left off on her next album, Broken Horses, with the emotional opener, "Right On Time."
  • Elton John is a huge fan of "The Joke." "I just love it," he remarked to The Guardian. "I've played it continuously. It's just the kind of song I could have written, quite Elton-ish."

Comments: 2

  • Catheirne from IrelandWhy was this song not written 20 years ago?. Are we to believe that those coming into our countries are the only one's being treated badly by our Governments?. We have lost the plot.
  • Loretta from ArkansasWow! So powerful and so inspiring. Thank you for the music, Brandi. You're a national treasure.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in Rock

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in RockSong Writing

We ring the Hell's Bells to see what songs and rockers are sincere in their Satanism, and how much of it is an act.

Bryan Adams

Bryan AdamsSongwriter Interviews

What's the deal with "Summer of '69"? Bryan explains what the song is really about, and shares more of his songwriting insights.

Rush: Album by Album - A Conversation With Martin Popoff

Rush: Album by Album - A Conversation With Martin PopoffSong Writing

A talk with Martin Popoff about his latest book on Rush and how he assessed the thousands of albums he reviewed.

Spooner Oldham

Spooner OldhamSongwriter Interviews

His keyboard work helped define the Muscle Shoals sound and make him an integral part of many Neil Young recordings. Spooner is also an accomplished songwriter, whose hits include "I'm Your Puppet" and "Cry Like A Baby."

Gary Brooker of Procol Harum

Gary Brooker of Procol HarumSongwriter Interviews

The lead singer and pianist for Procol Harum, Gary talks about finding the musical ideas to match the words.

Who's Johnny, And Why Does He Show Up In So Many Songs

Who's Johnny, And Why Does He Show Up In So Many SongsSong Writing

For songwriters, Johnny represents the American man. He has been angry, cool, magic, a rebel and, of course, marching home.