Album: Hard Candy (2002)

Charted: 33

License This Song 

• She comes out on Fridays every time
  And stands out in a line
  I could've been anyone she'd seen
  
  She waits another week to fall apart,
  She couldnt make another day
  I wish it was anyone but me
  I could've been anyone you see
  She had something breakable just under her skin
  
  American girls all weather and noise
  Playing the changes for all of the boys
  Holding a candle up to my hand
  Making it feel so incredible
  
  She comes out of closets every night
  But then she locks herself away
  Where she could keep everything from me
  I could've been anyone you see
  She's nothing but porcelain underneath her skin
  
  American girls are weather and noise
  Playing the changes for all of the boys
  Holding a candle right up to my hand
  Making me feel so incredible
  
  Little shiver shaking me everyday
  But I could get this same thing anywhere
  So if she goes away, well, it's alright and I'm ok
  She said come back again tonight
  and I said I might I might I might
  She said well that's alright
  If it's alright, it's alright with you
  And it's alright if it's alright with me
  
  I waited for an hour last Friday night, she never came around
  She took almost everything from me
  I'm goin' through my closets, tryin' on her clothes almost everyday
  
  I could've been anyone you see
  I wish it was anyone but me
  There's nothin but pills and ashes under my skin
  
  American girls are weather and noise
  Playing the changes for all of the boys
  Holding a candle right up to my hand
  Making me feel so incredible
  
  If I made you cry, please tell me why
  I'll try again if you let me try
  American girls are feathers and cream
  Come into bed so edible
  
  American girls, oh American girls
  American girls, oh oh oh oh
  American girls, oh American girls
  American girls, oh oh oh oh
  
  You made me cry
  You made me cry
  You made me cry
  You made me cry
  Yeah, you made me cry
  You made me cry
  Hey miss American girl
  Oh, oh oh oh oh
  Oh oh oh oh yeah
  Writer/s: ADAM FREDRIC DURITZ, BEN G MIZE, CHARLES THOMAS GILLINGHAM, DANIEL JOHN VICKREY, DAVID A IMMERGLUCK, DAVID LYNN BRYSON, MATTHEW MARK MALLEY
  Publisher: IMAGEM U.S. LLC , Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
  Lyrics licensed and provided by LyricFind

Comments: 8

• Mark from Elko, NvEver since I was a kid, I thought this song was about a dude that was a woman trapped in a man's body and he/she was having a difficult time coping. "I wish it was anyone but me. She could've been anyone you see.". But, the explanations above make sense too.
• Gabe from Antioch, CaShe's coming out of the closets she's doing drugs in. She locks herself away from him physically and emotionally, immune to his constant pleads for her to get help.
  The "little silver" he's talking about is heroin, instead of him changing her she changed him. She says come back tonight referring to come back tonight for more drugs. She never came last friday because she ran off with some other guy. She took his heart when he talks about almost everything, and she robbed his apartment. He's going through his closets meaning he's doing all the drugs she used to do. He wishes it was someone else becuz his heart is broken and he's on drugs.
  The last line in the chorus, when he refers to the incredible feeling he means the feeling of the drugs. The rest of the song sounds kinda gay, but he did get a dark message in there. Stay away from broken hearted girls, and drugs.
• Gabe from Antioch, CaShe comes out on Fridays every time to get her drugs. He was a random guy she saw on the streets that night, it could've been any guy. She's going to seduce him into taking her out and giving her money. She was clean for a week, but then started doing drugs again. The constant reference to "she had something breakable under her skin" is meant to allude to the needle she's using and her heart. American girls are all weather and noise because he's talking about the exhilarating emotions he goes through while being with the girl (happy, miserable, etc). The incredible feeling he's talking about is the love he feels for the girl.
  
• Liah from Kansas City, Moi agree with rain king. but i dont think the part about putting her clothes on is really what he is trying to put across. he is saying he has the same baggage as her, he bares the same clothes as her metaphorically.
• Kara from Montreal, QcAccording to Adam Duritz, this song is really quite simple..."Boy meets girl, boy falls in love with girl, girl leaves, boy wears the girls clothes."
• Charlie from Durham, EnglandAh comment below is SO right, I realised that all my favourite songs are superficially happy sounding, even poppy at times (tho a lot more folky) but all have deeper, sad meanings... I love the contrast!
  
  And though I am a dedicated fan of Crows, I can even agree with Jackh's comment - Duritz' voice can get a little whiney, my ex used to always groan when I put them on, tehe
• Rainking from Chicago, IlLike other CC songs, American Girls has a poppy sort of sound to it, but is very dark and depressing. It's about thinking you're in love, then realizing love has nothing to do with it. The girl didn't stay with him the one night because she liked him, it was because of her vulnerabilities and her frame of mind, etc. He could have been anyone that night. She just needed someone. Ironically, he's sort of in the same position as her. He's lonely. He needs somebody else too, but the difference is she meant something to him, but not vice-versa. You know you're pretty lonely and twisted when you're trying on some girl's clothes weeks after a one-night-stand, but there's something very honest and realistic about it. He's basically not a bad guy and his sensitivities are being trampled all over by this screwed-up, self-confident, but confused, American girl.
• Jackh from Spokane, WaI just dont like Counting Crows they bug me

More Songfacts:

American PieDon McLean

Don McLean's "American Pie" starts in mono and gradually goes to stereo. It isn't full stereo until the end of the song, which is over 8 minutes long.

Hangin' ToughNew Kids On The Block

"Hangin' Tough" came at the peak of New Kids On The Block mania (1988). Their writer/producer Maurice Starr wrote it about the struggles the band faced early on. It was a #1 hit in both America and the UK.

Scooby SnacksFun Lovin' Criminals

The Scooby Snacks in the Fun Lovin' Criminals song aren't dog treats, they're Valium pills.

The Girl Is MineMichael Jackson

The first single from the Thriller album was "The Girl Is Mine," chosen over "Billie Jean" and "Beat It" because it was a duet with Paul McCartney and thus guaranteed airplay.

CenterfieldJohn Fogerty

"Centerfield" was the first song enshrined in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame.

Love Never Felt So GoodMichael Jackson

Michael Jackson became the first artist in history to score Top 10 hits in five consecutive decades on the Hot 100 when "Love Never Felt So Good" landed at #9 on the chart dated May 31, 2014.

Editor's Picks

JJ Burnel of The StranglersSongwriter Interviews

JJ talks about The Stranglers' signature sound - keyboard and bass - which isn't your typical strain of punk rock.

John Doe of XSongwriter Interviews

With his X-wife Exene, John fronts the band X and writes their songs.

Glen BurtnikSongwriter Interviews

On Glen's résumé: hit songwriter, Facebook dominator, and member of Styx.

Dino Cazares of Fear FactorySongwriter Interviews

The guitarist/songwriter explains how he came up with his signature sound, and deconstructs some classic Fear Factory songs.

George HarrisonFact or Fiction

Did Eric Clapton really steal George's wife? What's the George Harrison-Monty Python connection? Set the record straight with our Fact or Fiction quiz.

Steely DanFact or Fiction

Did they really trade their guitarist to The Doobie Brothers? Are they named after something naughty? And what's up with the band name?