Too Good To Be True

Album: Deeper Well (2024)
Charted: 102
Play Video

Songfacts®:

  • Over a warm and inviting melody, Kacey Musgraves straddles the line between love and heartbreak with some clever wordplay on this track:

    Be good to me and I'll be good to you
    But please don't be too good to be true


    A possible inspiration for the song is Cole Schafer, a poet Musgraves dated for about two years. They split a few months before the song was released.
  • Kacey Musgraves co-wrote "Too Good to be True" with her frequent collaborators, Daniel Tashian and Ian Fitchuk. The two also collaborated with Musgraves on her albums Golden Hour (2018) and Star-Crossed (2021).

    Singer-songwriter Anna Nalick also gets credited because the song interpolates elements of her 2005 hit "Breathe (2 AM)."
  • "Too Good to be True" was released as the second single from Deeper Well on February 29, 2024. Musgraves recorded the album at Electric Lady in New York rather than in Nashville. "I was seeking some different environmental energy, and Electric Lady has the best mojo," said the country star.
  • Kacey Musgraves performed "Too Good To Be True" and "Deeper Well" on the March 2, 2024 episode of Saturday Night Live. This was the singer's third musical appearance on the long-running show.
  • The "Too Good To Be True" video was directed by Scott Cudmore (N.E.R.D., Feist, Justin Bieber). The clip is a mind-bending exploration of the song's themes, blurring the lines between reality and fantasy.

    We see Musgraves recording the song in the studio, but is that all there is? The video becomes a metanarrative, constantly questioning what's real and what's just a carefully crafted illusion. Are they "too good to be true," mirroring the song's central question?
  • "Too Good To Be True" explores the vulnerability of stepping into new love after past hurt. "It takes a lot of bravery to put yourself out there again," Kacey Musgraves shared with American Songwriter. "But I do think that's why we're here as humans, and it can be easy to stay in this little world, currently single world, where you can control every aspect of everything, and it feels good."

    "But you also grow a lot as a human by rubbing up against someone else's shortcomings and them rubbing up against yours," she continued. "And it's just scary. Conflict is inevitable with love. It's part of it. I think I was just in this mindset at that point in time of like, 'Okay, I'm opening myself up again here.'"

Comments: 1

  • Christy from OklahomaI'm glad she credited her. The instant I heard the song, I knew where I'd heard the vocal melody from.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Elton John

Elton JohnFact or Fiction

Does he have beef with Gaga? Is he Sean Lennon's godfather? See if you can tell fact from fiction in the Elton John edition.

Why Does Everybody Hate Nu-Metal? Your Metal Questions Answered

Why Does Everybody Hate Nu-Metal? Your Metal Questions AnsweredSong Writing

10 Questions for the author of Precious Metal: Decibel Presents the Stories Behind 25 Extreme Metal Masterpieces

Rick Astley

Rick AstleySongwriter Interviews

Rick Astley on "Never Gonna Give You Up," "Cry For Help," and his remarkable resurgence that gave him another #1 UK album.

Band Names

Band NamesFact or Fiction

Was "Pearl" Eddie Vedder's grandmother, and did she really make a hallucinogenic jam? Did Journey have a contest to name the group? And what does KISS stand for anyway?

90s Music Quiz 1

90s Music Quiz 1Music Quiz

First question: Michael Jordan and Magic Johnson appeared in videos for what artist?

Mick Jones of Foreigner

Mick Jones of ForeignerSongwriter Interviews

Foreigner's songwriter/guitarist tells the stories behind the songs "Juke Box Hero," "I Want To Know What Love Is," and many more.